Diesel vs. Electric: Can Diesel Be More Environmentally Friendly for Heavy Fleets?
Diesel has long been the fuel of choice for heavy-duty fleets due to its reliability, efficiency, and availability. As businesses face increasing pressure to reduce their environmental impact, many are considering electric vehicles (EVs) as an alternative. However, the conversation around "greener" fuels are more complex than it may first appear. In some cases, diesel can actually be a more environmentally friendly option, particularly when the full life cycle of energy production and consumption is considered. This article explores how diesel can still play a sustainable role in fleet management compared to other types of fuels, such as EVs, especially when considering the current energy mix and infrastructure.
Diesel Efficiency and Emission Reductions
- Modern Diesel Engines: Diesel engines have come a long way in terms of efficiency and emissions. Today’s modern diesel engines are cleaner and more efficient than ever, thanks to advancements like selective catalytic reduction (SCR) systems, diesel particulate filters (DPFs), and advanced fuel injection technologies. These innovations significantly reduce nitrogen oxide (NOx) and particulate matter emissions, making diesel more environmentally friendly than in the past.
- Longer Lifespan and Fuel Efficiency: Diesel engines tend to last longer and are more fuel-efficient for long-haul operations. When comparing the fuel economy of diesel with other fuels, diesel engines often consume less fuel per kilometre, which means fewer overall emissions per trip.
The Environmental Impact of Electric Fleets: A Closer Look
- Battery Production and Disposal: Another critical factor to consider is the environmental impact of EV battery production. Manufacturing large lithium-ion batteries for electric trucks requires the extraction of rare earth minerals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which have significant environmental and social impacts. Additionally, disposing of or recycling these batteries at the end of their life cycle presents another environmental challenge.
- While EVs are widely seen as the future of clean transportation, their environmental benefits are closely tied to how the electricity powering them is produced. Charging an electric fleet from a grid powered by fossil fuels can offset the environmental advantages of EVs.
- Electricity Grid Dependence: In many countries, including Australia, a significant portion of electricity still comes from coal and gas. If an EV fleet is charged using electricity generated from these sources, the overall emissions may not be as low as expected. According to the Australian Energy Regulator (AER), 54% of the electricity generated in Australia in 2022 came from coal, while only 32% came from renewable sources like wind and solar.
- Example: A heavy-duty electric truck charged in a region reliant on coal-fired power may produce more carbon emissions over its life cycle than a modern diesel truck with optimised fuel efficiency. This highlights the importance of considering the source of electricity when evaluating the environmental benefits of EVs.
Diesel’s Lower Infrastructure Impact
- Existing Infrastructure: Diesel infrastructure is well-established, meaning that switching to or maintaining a diesel fleet does not require the creation of new infrastructure, which itself has an environmental cost. Building EV charging stations, particularly for large fleets, requires significant investment in new infrastructure, including high-energy-demand charging systems that can strain the grid if not supported by renewable energy sources.
- Example: A company operating a fleet of diesel trucks can continue using existing refuelling infrastructure, while an electric fleet would require significant upgrades to depot charging facilities, which, if powered by non-renewable sources, may negate some of the environmental benefits of the switch.
Bio-Diesel and Renewable Diesel: Greener Diesel Options
Bio-Diesel: One way diesel can become more environmentally friendly is through the use of bio-diesel, a renewable fuel produced from vegetable oils, animal fats, and recycled cooking oil. Studies in Australia show that using bio-diesel blends such as B20 (20% bio-diesel, 80% petroleum diesel) can significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions. According to research conducted by the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), these biofuel options contribute to lowering emissions in sectors like transport by utilizing sustainable feedstocks and reducing lifecycle carbon emissions compared to traditional diesel fuels.
Renewable Diesel: Renewable diesel, made from organic waste materials, offers similar environmental benefits by providing a low-carbon alternative that is chemically compatible with existing diesel engines. Fleet operators can leverage these greener diesel alternatives to lower emissions without needing major infrastructure changes.
- Example: Fleet operators who switch to bio-diesel or renewable diesel can lower their carbon emissions significantly, making their diesel-powered operations more sustainable without needing to invest in new EV infrastructure.
Diesel’s Role in Hybrid Solutions
- Diesel-Electric Hybrids: Some fleets are exploring diesel-electric hybrid solutions as a middle ground. These vehicles use a combination of diesel fuel and electric power, reducing overall fuel consumption and emissions without entirely depending on the electricity grid. Hybrid diesel trucks are particularly well-suited for stop-and-go urban deliveries, where electric power can be used in low-emission zones, and diesel can be used for long highway trips.
- Example: A Sydney-based delivery company could use hybrid trucks to operate in inner-city low-emission zones, reducing emissions where they matter most. Relying on diesel for long-distance deliveries would ensure operational flexibility and lower overall emissions.
Practical Considerations: Diesel’s Reliability for Heavy-Duty Fleets
- Range and Payload Capacity: For long-haul operations and heavy-duty applications, diesel engines are currently more practical than EVs. Diesel trucks offer better range and can carry heavier loads without significantly impacting fuel efficiency. In contrast, electric trucks often face limitations in range, especially when carrying heavy cargo, and require frequent recharging, which may not be feasible in remote or underdeveloped areas.
- Example: A long-distance freight company operating in rural Australia may find diesel trucks more reliable and environmentally viable than EVs, particularly if recharging infrastructure is scarce or if renewable energy isn’t widely available in those regions.
While the push toward electric vehicles is an important step for sustainability, the environmental impact of EVs depends largely on the energy source used to power them. In regions where the electricity grid is still heavily reliant on fossil fuels, diesel can, in some cases, be a more environmentally friendly option for heavy-duty fleets, especially when combined with advances in diesel technology, bio-diesel, and renewable diesel options.
Partner with APW
References:
APW2U is designed to simplify your fuel management and provide you with unmatched convenience and cost savings. With our mobile diesel tanks installed directly at your business location, you gain complete control over your fleet’s fuelling needs.
Visit https://apwfuel.com.au/business-solutions-apw2u/ to explore more.
Get Connected with APW!
Website: https://apwfuel.com.au/
Facebook Page: www.facebook.com/apwfuel
Instagram: www.instagram.com/apw_wentworthville/
LinkedIn Page: www.linkedin.com/company/apwgroup/
YouTube Channel: www.youtube.com/@apw_group
For more information, please contact: marketing@apwfuel.com.au
